PolitiQuote

Political speech, timestamped and in context

Samuel Alito: “Suppose the claim is that this provision is not unconstitutional on its face because it's constitutional as…”

Featuring: Samuel Alito, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States | National

Watch on YouTube

Samuel Alito Raises Hypothetical About Benefits For Veterans Who Are Serving Life Sentence In Prison

Published

So I think based on the line that Robinson drew, I think the government would have a good argument that that can't proceed in district court. Suppose the claim is that this provision is not unconstitutional on its face because it's constitutional as applied to, let's say, veterans who are serving a term of life imprisonment without parole. And for them, there isn't the same need for the benefits that is experienced by a veteran who is living in the outside world. (01:01–01:19)

STATEMENT

Asserts that a statutory provision may be constitutional for certain groups, such as veterans serving life sentences.

This is an excerpt from a raw transcript. The assertions have not been audited or verified. Tap the video to view the source footage and understand the context.


Samuel Alito

See the main statements from Samuel Alito in this video

Report A Transcription Error

Please report any error in the automated transcription.

About PolitiQuote

PolitiQuote is a civic library index to statements made by politicians in publicly available video records.

PolitiQuote is a service of Gigafact Foundation, a nonpartisan nonprofit advancing facts and information transparency, community by community.

Visit gigafact.org to learn more.